top of page

The Gratitude Advantage: How Thankfulness Transforms School Leadership, Learning, and Life

Writer: Dr. Toby A. Travis
Dr. Toby A. Travis
Nov 10
6 min read

What if one of the most effective strategies for improving school culture, strengthening relationships, and increasing student engagement costs absolutely nothing?


Every November, we set aside time to give thanks. Families gather, schools celebrate, and we pause to acknowledge the blessings of another year. Yet, for those of us serving in education, Thanksgiving often arrives during one of the most demanding seasons of the school calendar.


Budgets need attention. Parents have concerns. Students struggle. Teachers are tired. And school leaders often find themselves spending considerably more time addressing what is wrong than celebrating what is right.


I have often observed that school leaders can spend an entire day resolving problems without recognizing the remarkable things happening around them. We become so focused on what needs improvement that we overlook what deserves appreciation.


What if gratitude were more than a seasonal sentiment? What if it were an intentional leadership practice with measurable implications for school effectiveness?


Research suggests that it is.


Gratitude Changes More Than Our Mood


Psychologists Robert Emmons and Michael McCullough (2003) helped establish the scientific foundation for understanding gratitude. Their experimental research found that individuals who intentionally recorded things they were thankful for experienced improvements in aspects of psychological well-being compared with those who focused on difficulties or ordinary events.


More recently, a comprehensive 2025 meta-analysis involving 145 studies and nearly 25,000 participants across 28 countries confirmed that gratitude interventions produce statistically significant, though generally modest, improvements in well-being.


In other words, gratitude is not simply something happy people express. Practicing gratitude can contribute to greater happiness.


This distinction matters. We do not have to wait until our circumstances improve before becoming grateful. Gratitude is a disposition we can intentionally cultivate, even when circumstances remain difficult.


And in education, our dispositions rarely affect us alone.


The Emotional Influence of Leadership


School leaders establish far more than policies, procedures, and priorities. Whether intentionally or not, they also influence the emotional climate of their organizations.


Research on emotional contagion demonstrates that attitudes and emotions spread through groups. In a landmark study, Barsade (2002) found that positive emotional influence improved cooperation, reduced conflict, and increased perceptions of group performance.


For school leaders, the implications are significant. The disposition we bring into a faculty meeting, classroom observation, or difficult parent conversation can influence how others experience that interaction.


More directly, researchers Lea Waters and Helen Stokes (2015) studied gratitude practices among 27 school leaders. They found that keeping gratitude journals helped leaders develop more balanced perspectives, recognize the value of relationships, and approach problems with greater appreciation. Writing gratitude letters encouraged stronger professional relationships and prompted others to express appreciation.


Interestingly, participants also acknowledged the tension between practicing gratitude and their responsibility to identify and solve problems.


That tension is familiar to anyone who has led a school.


Gratitude does not require us to ignore what is wrong. It helps us recognize what is right while addressing what needs to change.


A 2025 synthesis of 29 qualitative studies further identified appreciation, supportive relationships, and positive school culture among the leadership practices associated with teacher well-being.


Trust is strengthened when people know their contributions are seen, their efforts are valued, and their leader recognizes more than their shortcomings.


The Classroom Connection: Attitude Influences Achievement


The same principles extend into classrooms.


Consider two teachers presenting essentially the same lesson. Both understand the content and have prepared appropriate activities. One approaches the lesson with enthusiasm, curiosity, and genuine appreciation for the students. The other communicates frustration, fatigue, and little enthusiasm for the subject.


Would we expect students to experience those classrooms in the same way?


Research suggests otherwise.


A 2021 study involving 70 teachers and 1,537 ninth-grade mathematics students identified meaningful connections between teacher enthusiasm and student engagement. Teachers' and students' motivational experiences varied together across lessons.


A 2026 meta-analysis examining teacher emotional support found positive associations with student engagement, academic self-efficacy, and academic achievement. The associations were stronger for engagement and self-efficacy than for achievement itself.


These studies do not establish that gratitude alone raises test scores. They do, however, reinforce an important educational conviction: learning is relational, and the classroom's emotional environment matters.


Students benefit from teachers who communicate that learning is worthwhile, mistakes are opportunities for growth, and every learner has something valuable to contribute.


A grateful teacher notices progress, not simply performance. A grateful student begins recognizing opportunity where another might see only obligation.


And both contribute to a healthier learning community.


Five Ways to Build a Culture of Gratitude


If gratitude can strengthen well-being, relationships, and the conditions that support learning, how might we intentionally cultivate it throughout our school?


The opportunity belongs to everyone.


For school leaders: Make appreciation specific and personal. Rather than offering another generic thank-you to the faculty, identify something meaningful an individual has contributed. Explain what you noticed and why it mattered. Consider beginning leadership meetings by recognizing evidence of mission fulfillment before addressing problems. Appreciation should never replace accountability, but it can provide a healthier foundation for it.


For teachers: Celebrate growth, not merely achievement. Recognize the student who perseveres through a difficult concept, the classmate who encourages another learner, or the child who demonstrates unexpected kindness. Invite students to identify something they learned and someone who helped them learn it. Gratitude becomes especially meaningful when students recognize that their success rarely happens independently.


For parents: Make gratitude part of everyday family life. At the dinner table, ask each family member to share something they are thankful for and why. Model appreciation for teachers, school staff, and others who invest in your children. Our children learn much about gratitude by observing how we speak about the people serving them.


For students: Practice noticing and expressing appreciation. Consider writing a note to someone who has made a difference in your life. Thank a teacher, coach, parent, or friend for something specific. Recognize that opportunities to learn, grow, and serve are gifts worth appreciating, even when they require considerable effort.


For Christian educators: Connect gratitude to worship and stewardship. Scripture calls believers to give thanks in all circumstances (1 Thessalonians 5:18). This does not mean every circumstance is good or that suffering should be dismissed. Rather, our gratitude is grounded in God's goodness and faithfulness, whose character remains constant even when our circumstances change.


In Christian education, gratitude should be more than a devotional topic each November. It should influence how we lead, teach, correct, encourage, and serve.


We recognize students as individuals created in God's image. We acknowledge the privilege of partnering with families. We celebrate the calling of teachers and the opportunity to participate in God's work through education.


Gratitude, properly understood, directs our attention beyond ourselves.


A Thanksgiving Challenge


As Thanksgiving approaches, I invite you to try something simple.


For the next seven days, identify three things you are grateful for. Then intentionally express your appreciation to at least one person each day.


Be specific. Be sincere. And pay attention to what happens in your relationships, conversations, and perspective.


We cannot control every challenge our schools face. We can, however, choose how we respond to those challenges and how we treat the people navigating them alongside us.


Perhaps the greatest opportunity this Thanksgiving is not simply to count our blessings but to become a blessing to others.


Gratitude may begin as a personal discipline, but its greatest influence is often experienced by the people around us.


And that is something worth giving thanks for.


References


Research supporting the article, with links to original publications.


  1. Barsade, S. G. (2002). The ripple effect: Emotional contagion and its influence on group behavior. Administrative Science Quarterly, 47(4), 644–675. Study

  2. Choi, H., et al. (2025). A meta-analysis of the effectiveness of gratitude interventions on well-being across cultures. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 122(28). Study

  3. Emmons, R. A., & McCullough, M. E. (2003). Counting blessings versus burdens: An experimental investigation of gratitude and subjective well-being in daily life. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 84(2), 377–389. Study

  4. Fu, X., & Zhou, X. (2026). The impact of perceived teacher emotional support on student learning: A meta-analysis. Behavioral Sciences, 16(8), 1322. Study

  5. Waters, L., & Stokes, H. (2015). Positive education for school leaders: Exploring the effects of emotion-gratitude and action-gratitude. The Educational and Developmental Psychologist, 32(1), 1–22. Study

  6. Ting, S.-C., & Feng, S.-C. (2019). Concrete actions of gratitude leadership of elementary school principals and the influences on the schools. Forum of Educational Administration, 11(1), 15–52. Study


Research and editorial assistance: Generative AI was used to help identify relevant studies, organize the article, and refine language. The author retains responsibility for the interpretation, conclusions, and final content.


©2026 Toby A. Travis, Ed.D.

Comments


bottom of page